News, Media and Opinions

Story · all 20 words

The Story That Was Not True

It started, as these things always start now, with a message on a family group chat. My uncle sent a photograph and one line of text, and within about forty minutes eleven people had shared it and two of them had telephoned my mother about it.

The headline said that a factory near our town was closing and that four hundred people would lose their jobs. My cousin works at that factory. My aunt cried.

It was not true. Or rather, a small piece of it had been true, eighteen months earlier, in a different town, about a different company. Somebody had taken a real article from 2023, changed the name of the place, and put a new photograph on the top of it.

What I found interesting, once the panic had passed, was how easy it had been to check. It took me about ninety seconds. The photograph appeared on four other websites with four different stories attached. There was no source named anywhere in the text, no journalist credited, and no date. Three signs, all visible before you read a single sentence.

The news that evening reported nothing about it, because there was nothing to report. No channel mentioned it. Nobody broadcast a word. That absence is itself information, and I think it is the most useful thing I have learned in ten years: when something enormous is supposedly happening and no serious organisation is saying so, the story is almost certainly fake.

The debate at dinner on the Friday was long and loud and better than I expected. My uncle was embarrassed and therefore argumentative, which is normal. My mother said the sentence that ended it: that it does not matter who sent it, only that we all stop sending it.

What stayed with me was my cousin’s point of view. She had spent two hours believing she was losing her job, and she said something I have thought about since – that she had believed it instantly, not because the story was convincing, but because she had been quietly frightened of exactly that for a year. The rumour did not persuade her. It simply arrived in a place that was already prepared for it.

That is why this is difficult. It is never really about the fact, and it is not even really about the opinion. It is about what you were already expecting to be true.

We did not all end up agreeing. I agree with my uncle about very little and I disagree with him loudly about most things, and after thirty years neither of us has managed to convince the other of anything at all. But we did agree on one rule, and the family has more or less kept it: before you forward something, say where it came from. According to whom? If you cannot answer that in one sentence, do not send it.

It is not a perfect rule. It has cut the traffic on that group chat by about half, which my aunt considers a loss and I consider the entire point.